AH v BH: Nuptial Agreement & Needs Principle ================================================ Since Vardags won the landmark Supreme Court case, *[Radmacher v Granatino](https://vardags.com/law-guide/important-divorce-cases/radmacher-v-granatino),* prenuptial agreements have had a new and important status in matrimonial law, and it is likely you will be bound by it if you divorce. When determining a financial settlement, the Court first looks for a nuptial agreement that outlines how the assets should be divided. Nuptial agreements specify the division of a couple's assets and income, limiting the divorce court's discretion in apportioning the wealth. Overview: AH v BH \[2024\] EWFC 125 ----------------------------------- The case of [*AH v BH* \[2024\] EWFC 125](https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWFC/HCJ/2024/125.html) is a pivotal example of how UK courts may **depart from the terms of a nuptial agreement** when doing so is necessary to meet the [**needs** ](https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=2ahUKEwiFqem3jPSOAxXtVEEAHfDTHYsQFnoECBsQAQ&url=https://vardags.com/law-guide/how-the-courts-decide-a-financial-settlement/the-needs-principle&usg=AOvVaw0OVvWFyj14aq3eiB0xopw3&opi=89978449)of one party - especially where children are involved. > **Key Principle:** > While nuptial agreements carry significant weight following *Radmacher v Granatino*, they are not absolute. Courts retain discretion to override them if enforcing the agreement would result in unfairness. Case Background: ---------------- - This case concerned a marriage of around 5.5 years including a period of cohabitation. - The parties entered into a prenuptial agreement prior to the marriage which sought to ringfence the assets in the husband's sole name, notably his business interests. - The parties signed the prenuptial agreement with full knowledge of its meaning and consequences and with the benefit of legal advice, and the wife understood that it would severely limit her financial remedies claim on divorce. The main issue in this case was the interplay between the prenuptial agreement and the financial needs of the wife as well as the two children of the marriage, to whom the wife is and will remain the primary carer. When the marriage broke down, the assets were significant with almost £50 million in the husband's sole name in contrast to the wife's assets of £291,000. The family home was in the husband's sole name, but the wife had made financial contributions towards its renovation from sale proceeds of her flat. The wife did not dispute the validity of the prenuptial agreements but instead claimed that it should be departed from to meet her reasonable financial needs. Judgment: ---------- In leading the judgement, Mr Justice Peel departed from the prenuptial agreement. He decided that the family home should be sold with the wife receiving 56.7% among other assets. The main points to note are that the wife's role as the primary carer to the children for the rest of their minority was regarded as a powerful counterweight to pre-nuptial agreements as she had no alternative property of her own and cannot be expected to return to her corporate career. Secondly, the nuptial agreement provided that it should be reviewed upon childbirth but never was, suggesting that it was contemplated to be unfair upon the birth of children. Legal Significance ------------------ **Although the prenuptial agreement in this case complied with the conditions set out in Radmacher, Mr Justice Peel departed from its terms on the basis that it did not reflect the wife's long-term responsibilities for the children and her lack of independent wealth in contrast to the husband.** This decision emphasises the importance of ensuring that a nuptial agreement provides for important life events such as childbirth. Ensuring that needs can be met in these circumstances increase the likelihood of the agreement being upheld by the court on divorce. ### **Need Expert Help?** **Vardags offers unparalleled expertise in prenuptial agreements for high-net-worth individuals. Following our landmark success in *Radmacher v Granatino*, we have set the standard for drafting and enforcing agreements that safeguard substantial assets and complex financial interests, both domestically and internationally. To discuss how we can protect your wealth with a bespoke prenuptial agreement, contact our expert team today.** **Alternatively, if you're concerned about how a nuptial agreement may affect your divorce settlement, especially where children or financial disparity are involved, our expert solicitors can help.** **We offer a free initial consultation to qualifying individuals.** [BOOK FREE CONSULTATION](https://vardags.com/contact "BOOK FREE CONSULTATION") About Us -------- Ayesha VardagFounder & President "A DIVORCE LAWYER WIDELY REGARDED AS ONE OF THE WORLD'S BEST" The Metro Vardags offer a unique approach to the law, specially tailored to the needs of HNW individuals. We offer City-quality representation for your divorce and family law needs. Our lawyers come from the very best universities and receive the very best training - they are determined, diligent, and dedicated to getting the best outcome... [read more](https://vardags.com/about-us) [BOOK FREE CONSULTATION](https://vardags.com/contact) Related Guides -------------- [Are Nuptial Agreements Binding in Divorce?](https://vardags.com/law-guide/how-the-courts-decide-a-financial-settlement/are-nuptial-agreements-binding "Are Nuptial Agreements Binding in Divorce?") [Enforcing a nuptial agreement](https://vardags.com/law-guide/nuptial-agreements/enforcing-a-nuptial-agreement "Enforcing a nuptial agreement") [How do international elements affect a nuptial agreement?](https://vardags.com/law-guide/how-the-courts-decide-a-financial-settlement/how-do-international-elements-affect-nuptial-agreements "How do international elements affect a nuptial agreement?") [Is there a nuptial agreement?](https://vardags.com/law-guide/how-the-courts-decide-a-financial-settlement/is-there-a-nuptial-agreement "Is there a nuptial agreement?") [The criteria for a valid nuptial agreement](https://vardags.com/law-guide/nuptial-agreements/criteria-for-a-valid-nuptial-agreement "The criteria for a valid nuptial agreement") [The criteria for a valid nuptial agreement: predicament of real need](https://vardags.com/law-guide/nuptial-agreements/predicament-of-real-need "The criteria for a valid nuptial agreement: predicament of real need") The information on this website is intended as a guide and does not constitute legal advice. Vardags do not accept liability for any errors in the information on this website, nor any losses stemming from reliance upon the statements made herein. All articles and pages aim to reflect the legal position at time they were published, and may have been rendered obsolete by subsequent developments in the law. Should you require specialist advice, tailored to your situation, please see how Vardags can help you. OUR LEADERSHIP TEAM ------------------- [### Ayesha Vardag](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/ayesha-vardag "Ayesha Vardag Founder & President Divorce & Family") [### Stephen Bence](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/stephen-bence "Stephen Bence Vardags CEO") [### David Lister](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/david-lister "David Lister") [Founder & President](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/ayesha-vardag "Ayesha Vardag Founder & President Divorce & Family") [Chief Executive Officer](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/stephen-bence "Stephen Bence Vardags CEO") [Senior Partner and Head of London Family - Divorce & Family](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/david-lister "David Lister") [### Ayesha Vardag Founder & President ](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/ayesha-vardag "Ayesha Vardag Founder & President Divorce & Family")"Ayesha Vardag - Britain's top divorce lawyer." The Telegraph [### Stephen Bence Chief Executive Officer](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/stephen-bence "Stephen Bence Vardags CEO")"Dr Stephen Bence is a financial genius." Lewis Marks KC [### David Lister Senior Partner and Head of London Family - Divorce & Family ](https://vardags.com/solicitors/london/david-lister "David Lister")"Brilliant with a real spark which clients love" Legal 500 [Meet the rest of the team](https://vardags.com/team) [Vardags climbs ranks of UK's biggest firms in The Lawyer's UK 200](https://vardags.com/posts/vardags-london-climbs-ranks-of-uks-biggest-firms-in-the-lawyers-uk-200)