The Agbaje Case: How will the level of provision be determined? =============================================================== Agbaje v Agbaje: How the English Courts Determine Financial Provision After an Overseas Divorce ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Under Part III of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984, individuals who have divorced abroad may apply for **financial relief in the English courts** - provided they have a significant connection to England or Wales. This provision also applies to civil partnerships. The landmark case of [**Agbaje v Agbaje \[2010\] UKSC 13**](https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKSC/2010/13.html) clarified how courts should approach these applications and under what circumstances financial provision may be granted. **If you think that inadequate financial provisions have been made by a foreign court in your overseas divorce, click below for a free initial consultation with one of our expert divorce solicitors.** [BOOK FREE CONSULTATION](https://vardags.com/contact "BOOK FREE CONSULTATION") Background of the agbaje case: ------------------------------- - Mr and Mrs Agbaje were married for 38 years, both Nigerian by birth. - They had met in England in the 1960s and acquired UK citizenship in 1972. - All five of their children were born in England and in 1975, Mr Agbaje had bought a property in England in which their children stayed with a nanny. - For most of their married life, Mr and Mrs Agbaje lived in Nigeria, although four out of five of their children were educated in England. Upon separation in 1999, Mrs Agbaje moved to their property in England. In 2003, Mr Agbaje issued divorce proceedings in the Nigerian courts in which Mrs Agbaje sought ancillary relief. The Nigerian court awarded her a life interest in a property in Lagos (capital value of around £86,000) and a lump sum of approximately £21,000. Beliving this to be inadequate, Mrs Agbaje then sought relief under Part III of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984. The High Court granted her leave - as required under Part III - and ultimately ordered that she should receive a lump sum equal to 65% of the sale proceeds of their property in England (equivalent to around £275,000) on condition that she relinquish her life interest in the Lagos property. The award represented 39% of the assets. The Court of Appeal set aside the whole of the English award on the ground that the High Court had given insufficient weight to the connections of the case with Nigeria, however, the Supreme Court later unanimously allowed the wife's appeal and restored the order of the High Court. Supreme Court Ruling: Key Clarifications ---------------------------------------- First, it was held that Part III is to be applied to alleviate the adverse consequences of no or inadequate financial provisions being made by a foreign court in a situation where the parties had substantial connections with England. Thus, in applying Part III, the English courts should not be deciding whether it would be appropriate for an order to be made by a court in England or Wales as opposed to a foreign court. **Instead, the focus of Part III is to alleviate hardship caused by inadequate financial provision in a foreign divorce, where there is a substantial connection to England.** Second, in deciding whether an order should be made, and if so, what order, the Supreme Court held that several factors will be relevant. This includes: - The financial benefit which the applicant has already received - Whether the applicant has failed to take advantage of a right under the foreign law to claim financial relief - The hardship or injustice which would result if no award were made ### Limits of relief It was also made clear that the intention of the legislation was not to allow a simple "top-up" of the foreign award to equate with an English award in every case. Instead, the strength of the connection with England should be considered to determine whether it is appropriate to use Part III to "top-up" the award. If the English connections are strong, however, it may be appropriate to do so. General principles for determining provision -------------------------------------------- Although the amount of financial provision awarded under Part III will depend on all the circumstances of the case, **three general principles** will be applied: 1. Primary consideration to be given to the welfare of any child of the marriage. 2. The award must not exceed what would have been granted had the case been heard entirely in England. 3. The order should have the result that provision is made for the reasonable needs of each spouse, where possible. About Us -------- Ayesha VardagFounder & President "A DIVORCE LAWYER WIDELY REGARDED AS ONE OF THE WORLD'S BEST" The Metro Vardags offer a unique approach to the law, specially tailored to the needs of HNW individuals. We offer City-quality representation for your divorce and family law needs. Our lawyers come from the very best universities and receive the very best training - they are determined, diligent, and dedicated to getting the best outcome... [read more](https://vardags.com/about-us) [BOOK FREE CONSULTATION](https://vardags.com/contact) OUR FOREIGN DESKS ----------------- Our foreign desks are comprised of top multi-lingual lawyers, with a network of international contacts. [Australia Desk](https://vardags.com/international/australia "Australia Desk") [Bahrain Desk](https://vardags.com/international/bahrain "Bahrain Desk") [BVI Desk](https://vardags.com/international/bvi "BVI Desk") [Belgium Desk](https://vardags.com/international/belgium "Belgium Desk") [Bermuda Desk](https://vardags.com/international/bermuda "Bermuda Desk") [Canada Desk](https://vardags.com/international/canada "Canada Desk") [Cayman Islands Desk](https://vardags.com/international/cayman-islands "Cayman Islands Desk") [China Desk](https://vardags.com/international/china "China Desk") [Dubai (UAE) Desk](https://vardags.com/international/dubai "Dubai (UAE) Desk") [France Desk](https://vardags.com/international/france "France Desk") [Germany Desk](https://vardags.com/international/germany "Germany Desk") [Gibraltar Desk](https://vardags.com/international/gibraltar "Gibraltar Desk") [Greece Desk](https://vardags.com/international/greece "Greece Desk") [Guernsey Desk](https://vardags.com/international/guernsey "Guernsey Desk") [Hong Kong Desk](https://vardags.com/international/hong-kong "Hong Kong Desk") [India Desk](https://vardags.com/international/india "India Desk") [Italy Desk](https://vardags.com/international/italy "Italy Desk") [Jersey Desk](https://vardags.com/international/jersey "Jersey Desk") [Kuwait Desk](https://vardags.com/international/kuwait "Kuwait Desk") [Republic of Ireland Desk](https://vardags.com/international/republic-of-ireland "Republic of Ireland Desk") [Liechtenstein Desk](https://vardags.com/international/liechtenstein "Liechtenstein Desk") [Luxembourg Desk](https://vardags.com/international/luxembourg "Luxembourg Desk") [Malaysia Desk](https://vardags.com/international/malaysia "Malaysia Desk") [Malta Desk](https://vardags.com/international/malta "Malta Desk") [Mauritius Desk](https://vardags.com/international/mauritius "Mauritius Desk") [Monaco Desk](https://vardags.com/international/monaco "Monaco Desk") [Netherlands Desk](https://vardags.com/international/netherlands "Netherlands Desk") [New Zealand Desk](https://vardags.com/international/new-zealand "New Zealand Desk") [Oman Desk](https://vardags.com/international/oman "Oman Desk") [Russia Desk](https://vardags.com/international/russia "Russia Desk") [United States of America Desk](https://vardags.com/international/united-states-america "United States of America Desk") [Portugal Desk](https://vardags.com/international/portugal "Portugal Desk") [Poland Desk](https://vardags.com/international/poland "Poland Desk") [Qatar Desk](https://vardags.com/international/qatar "Qatar Desk") [Saudi Arabia Desk](https://vardags.com/international/saudi-arabia "Saudi Arabia Desk") [Scotland Desk](https://vardags.com/international/scotland "Scotland Desk") [Singapore Desk](https://vardags.com/international/singapore "Singapore Desk") [South Africa Desk](https://vardags.com/international/south-africa "South Africa Desk") [Spain Desk](https://vardags.com/international/spain "Spain Desk") [Switzerland Desk](https://vardags.com/international/switzerland "Switzerland Desk") Related Reads ------------- ### Vardags' client secures England's largest ever Part III award On 12 October 2016 Nicholas Cusworth QC, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, awarded Sareh... [READ MORE](https://vardags.com/family-law/vardags-client-englands-largest-ever-part-iii-award "Vardags' client secures England's largest ever Part III award") Related Guides -------------- [Can I get financial provision in England and Wales after divorcing abroad?](https://vardags.com/law-guide/financial-provision-after-overseas-divorce/financial-provision-in-england-and-wales-after-divorcing-abroad "Can I get financial provision in England and Wales after divorcing abroad?") [Making the application for financial provision after an overseas divorce](https://vardags.com/law-guide/financial-provision-after-overseas-divorce/making-application-for-financial-provision-after-overseas-divorce "Making the application for financial provision after an overseas divorce") [The Potanin v Potanina threshold](https://vardags.com/law-guide/financial-provision-after-overseas-divorce/potanin-v-potanina-threshold "The Potanin v Potanina threshold") The information on this website is intended as a guide and does not constitute legal advice. Vardags do not accept liability for any errors in the information on this website, nor any losses stemming from reliance upon the statements made herein. All articles and pages aim to reflect the legal position at time they were published, and may have been rendered obsolete by subsequent developments in the law. Should you require specialist advice, tailored to your situation, please see how Vardags can help you.