Surrogate gives birth to her mother's baby ========================================== ![Surrogate gives birth to her mother's baby](https://vardags.com/images/pictures/_360/912333b8c27f1c73503277448bb144af.jpeg)A young mother who had given birth to her mother's child [featured](https://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/family/daughter-gave-birth-baby/) in the Sunday Telegraph last week, in the most recent of family surrogacy arrangements to attract media attention. Catherine aged 30, who is married with children of her own, agreed to carry a child for her mother Jacky Edwards, 47, who had recently remarried. The mother and daughter spoke to the newspaper about how Jacky and her husband Paul came to stay in Catherine's home for a week. Using plastic syringes and the measurement pots from children's medicine bottles, Catherine was inseminated with Jacky's husband's semen twice a day. Catherine successfully carried the child to term, eventually giving birth with Jacky and Paul with her in the delivery room. As Paul was the biological father, Catherine was able to subsequently sign a parental order recognizing Paul and Jacky as parents without them needing to adopt the baby. Family surrogacy arrangements like theirs are not uncommon in the UK where commercial surrogacy is outlawed. There are stringent restrictions on how surrogacy arrangements can be advertised and the would-be parents cannot secure their parental status ahead of the birth with a contract. From the baby's birth until the signing of the parental order, Catherine was his legal mother. In UK law the woman that gives birth to the child is always the legal mother, prior to adoption. This is the case no matter where in the world the child was conceived. [The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2008/22/contents) is very clear on this point: Section 33 (1) HFEA 2008 provides, 'The woman who is carrying or has carried a child as a result of the placing in her of an embryo or of sperm and eggs, and no other woman, is to be treated as the mother of the child.' As per section 35 of the same act, her husband was listed on the birth certificate as the child's legal father, even though he was not the biological father. This is because in UK law the surrogate's spouse will be considered a parent, unless they did not consent to the pregnancy. No parental order has ever been refused but surrogates and their partners cannot be compelled by law to hand over a child to the intended parents simply because of a prior agreement. Furthermore single people cannot by law apply for parental orders; rather a couple in an "enduring family relationship" must apply jointly. However in one high profile case B, a 24 year old single, gay man, was granted an order to adopt A, his biological son by surrogacy and legal brother. Knowing her son was desperate for a child, B's mother agreed to be implanted with the embryo formed from a donor egg and her son's sperm. In the [judgment](https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/markup.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWFC/HCJ/2015/17.html&query=cabeza&method=boolean) Mrs Justice Theis noted that the arrangement was not one that the court or the clinic had previously encountered but was "entirely lawful". She was satisfied that "an adoption order will provide the legal security to A's relationship with B, which will undoubtedly meet A's long term welfare needs. UK surrogacy law has been criticised for being undeveloped and unaccommodating. However there is currently little appetite in the general public for reform and widespread opposition to the kind of commercial surrogacy seen overseas. However with demand for fertility treatments rising and routes to international surrogacy closing up we should expect, in the coming years to see many more surrogacy arrangements like the one between Jacky Edwards and her daughter Catherine. "Ayesha Vardag - Britain's top divorce lawyer." ![The Huffington Post](https://vardags.com/images/logo/huffpost.png) "Ayesha Vardag - Woman of the Year"![GG2](https://vardags.com/images/logo/gg2-3.png) "Leading, Magic Circle law firm."Mr Justice Coleridge "A handful of firms dominate the so-called 'glamour' end of the market ... Vardags"The Times "One of the best divorce lawyers in the country"Marie Claire "Ayesha Vardag - 'diva of divorce' for the world's super rich" ![BBC](https://vardags.com/images/logo/bbc.png) "Dr Stephen Bence is a financial genius."Lewis Marks KC "Ayesha Vardag - the Queen of divorce"Daily Mail "Vardags brilliantly argued my case to a resounding victory"Pauline Chai (client) "Britain's top divorce lawyer" ![The Telegraph](https://vardags.com/images/logo/telegraph.png) More Family Law news -------------------- [Practice Direction 12D amended following Munby P's judgment 'In the matter of a Ward of Court [2017]'](https://vardags.com/family-law/practice-direction-12d-amended-munby-p-in-the-matter-of-a-ward-of-court "Practice Direction 12D amended following Munby P's judgment 'In the matter of a Ward of Court 2017'") [Brexit uncertainty factors in international child relocation case](https://vardags.com/family-law/international-child-relocation-case-brexit "Brexit uncertainty factors in international child relocation case") [Surrogate gives birth to her mother's baby](https://vardags.com/family-law/surrogate-gives-birth-to-her-mothers-baby "Surrogate gives birth to her mother's baby") [Baroness Hale has](https://vardags.com/family-law/baroness-hale-childrens-rights-in-the-family-courts "Baroness Hale has") [All going on a summer holiday? Things you should know before taking your child abroad](https://vardags.com/family-law/taking-your-child-abroad-on-holiday "All going on a summer holiday? Things you should know before taking your child abroad") Articles by Thea Dunne ---------------------- [Divorce proceedings and financial disputes to be separated](https://vardags.com/family-law/divorce-financial-proceedings-delinked "Divorce proceedings and financial disputes to be separated") [Divorce wave pulls up house prices in Hong Kong](https://vardags.com/family-law/house-prices-and-divorce-rise-hong-kong "Divorce wave pulls up house prices in Hong Kong") [Surrogate gives birth to her mother's baby](https://vardags.com/family-law/surrogate-gives-birth-to-her-mothers-baby "Surrogate gives birth to her mother's baby") [British pensioners passing up on matrimony](https://vardags.com/family-law/unmarried-older-couples-miss-tax-breaks "British pensioners passing up on matrimony") [Japanese princess set to lose royal status by marrying a commoner](https://vardags.com/family-law/japanese-princess-losing-royal-status "Japanese princess set to lose royal status by marrying a commoner")