A 50 year-old pizza baker from Padua, Northern Italy was granted permission to pay his ex-wife alimony in pizza—entitling her to €400 worth of pies and calzoni every month.
A chance discovery in Padua courthouse by an Italian reporter has thrust a truly remarkable family law story into the spotlight. As The Telegraph reports, journalist Lino Lava, on the look out for new scoops, came across a case where a man was acquitted for not paying child maintenance. His curiousity piqued due to the rarity of such a ruling, Mr Lava decided that the case warranted a closer look.
The case concerned Nicola Toso and Nicoletta Zuin ,who divorced in 2002, when their daughter was six years-old. In accordance with the divorce settlement, Mr Toso subsequently paid €400 per month in child support.
However, in 2008, the global economic crisis began to take its toll on Mr Toso’s finances. This, he claims, coupled with the fact that he had remarried and fathered three more children, left him unable to pay the figure.
His solution to this predicament was certainly creative. In lieu of cash, Mr Toso began offering Ms Zuin complementary dishes from the pizzeria he managed.
As presiding judge Chiara Bitozzi wrote in her ruling, this offer was “promptly rejected as ‘beggar’s change’”. Ms Zuin then filed a criminal complaint against Mr Toso.
Sonia Della Greca, Mr Toso’s attorney, refuted the claim that Mr Toso’s offer was an attempt to fob off his ex-wife. Mr Toso’s financial misfortunes were genuine, she argued, pointing out that the baker’s debts had forced him to eventually close the pizzeria in 2010.
Furthermore, Mr Toso had upheld all other parental responsibilities towards his eldest child, keeping visitations and, according to his daughter’s own deposition, integrating her into his new family unit.
In 2011, the daughter, then 13 years-old, decided to reside with her father, after her relationship with her mother broke down. Judge Bitozzi then ruled that it was Ms Zuin who, from then on, would be required to pay Mr Toso €300 per month in child support.
There was no evidence that the father had committed a crime, the court ruled.
Vardags’ team of top divorce lawyers delivers bespoke legal services to HNW and UHNW individuals, their families and businesses. Learn more from Vardags’ divorce guides.
Vardags Limited is a limited company trading as Vardags, Company No 7199468, registered in England and Wales, having its registered office at 10 Old Bailey, London EC4M 7NG. Vardags is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA Number 535955). Its VAT number is 99 001 7230.
Vardags uses the term ‘Partner’ as a professional title only, to describe a Senior Solicitor, Employee or Consultant with relevant experience, expertise and qualifications (whether legally qualified or otherwise) to merit the title. Our Partners are not partners in the legal sense. They are not liable for the debts, liabilities or obligations of Vardags Limited. Similarly, the term ’Director’ is a professional title only, to describe an employee or consultant of Vardags with relevant experience, expertise and qualifications to merit the title. It does not necessarily imply that the relevant individual is a director of Vardags Limited.
A list of the directors of Vardags Limited and a list of the names of those using the title of ’Director’ and ’Partner’ together with their official status is available for inspection at Vardags’ registered office.